Abstract
The purpose ofthis work was to ascertain the availability and utilization oflibrary resources in the teaching and learning ofreading comprehension in schools in Obollo-Afor Education Zone. Five research questions were formulated to guide the study. The design of the study was a descriptive survey while the population comprised 46 schools, 139 English Language teachers,
11,321 senior secondary students in the sampled schools in Obollo-Afor Education Zone. The sample size was 400 including students and teachers. Multistage sampling technique was used to select the schools while simple random sampling technique was used to select the students and teachers as the respondents for the study. A structured questionnaire titled availability and utilization oflibrary resources questionnaire was used. The data was analyzed using percentage, mean & standard deviation while three null hypotheses raisedfor the study was analyzed using t-test statistics. The major findings of the study is that many library resources such as dictionaries, manuals, maps, textbooks, magazines, newspaper, articles, novels, picture books,
graphs and internet are available in the library . Out ofthe 11 (eleven) available resources, only
6 (six) are utilized in secondary schools in Obollo-Afor Education Zone. Another finding was
also that both teachers and students possess the skills for using the resources while teaching, but are not aware of the need to use the available resources when it comes to the teaching and learning of reading comprehension. A number of recommendations were made towards the improvement of library use but the most prominent suggestion was that Ministry of Education and stake holders should organize workshops and seminars for English Language teachers in order to increase their level ofawareness on the need to use the resources.
CHAPTER ONE
INTRODUCTION
Background of the Study
Reading is a complex process which involves active interaction and negotiation between the reader and the author. This is because the reader tries to grasp the author’s purpose of writing the text being read. Davis (2014) defined reading as a process of looking at a series of written symbols and getting meaning from them. This means that, as the reader reads, the reader uses the eyes to receive written symbols (letters, spaces, punctuation marks) and the reader uses the brain to convert the written symbols into words, sentences, and paragraphs in order to make meaning out of it. According to Alfassi (2010) reading is a key skill that enables students to function efficiently and successfully apart from its use in examination. This implies that reading is an important skill that not only helps learners in the mastery of English but also, enhances students’ abilities in other areas of life. For this reason, reading requires adequate decoding skill; hence, teaching reading should be done in meaningful contexts since reading involves the understanding of written symbols and alphabets. People actually read for many reasons, but the main purpose of reading is understanding.
The understanding which results from reading is called comprehension. Without comprehension, reading is nothing more than tracking symbols on a page of paper with the eyes and sounding them out. According to Wright and Cervetti (2016), comprehension is the process of getting information in order to extract meaning out of it. This implies that in order to arrive at a meaning; a reader must take hold of the writer’s message through combining printed words to form messages. Reading comprehension is very important because without comprehension, reading does not provide readers with any meaningful information.
1
Reading comprehension could be described as the processing of symbols to get ideas, relating ideas to experience, organizing ideas, evaluating the ideas and utilizing the ideas for required purpose (Eze, 2013). In reading comprehension, some intellectual preparations are needed by the reader in order to comprehend what is being read. This is because, comprehension does not only mean glancing on letters and words, but meaning resides in the mind of the person who wrote the symbols, therefore, comprehension is not found on the printed symbols but in the mind of the reader who reads the written letters or alphabets. This is why comprehension becomes building bridges between the known and the unknown. Comprehension therefore, involves interpretation of what is read in accordance with prior knowledge. It also involves a lot
of influence making and this is why it is an active and constructive process which involves the
use of textual cues and the reader’s background knowledge to build a model of the author’s intended meaning.
Reading comprehension is important for students especially at senior secondary school levels because it has been observed by Opara (2012) that most of the students spend the majority of their days in content -area instructions such as English language, Mathematics, Commerce, Government, Biology, Agriculture among others. To English (2016), readers requires school• wide instructional practices integrated into content-area instruction in order to comprehend specific texts and grasp the concepts being communicated in them. Opara further suggests that as students advance in school, reading instruction should become more disciplinary (tied to content areas) and reinforcing, in order to support students’ academic ability. Comprehension, therefore, is necessary while reading, and when reading is badly taught, it leads to poor academic achievement not only in English language but in other subjects as well. For this reason, students should strive to comprehend specific texts in order to grasp the concepts and ideas or knowledge
2
being communicated in the text. The question now is with all the importance attached to reading, why do secondary school students still find reading comprehension difficult?
Despite the fact that adequate reading skills facilitates students’ achievement in reading comprehension, most secondary school students still find it difficult to read and understand. This may be as a result of the teaching and learning process or methods employed by the teachers and students. According to Adler & Van Doren (2014), a child’s inadequate reading skill may lead the child to having slow reading rate, slow comprehension, difficulty in distinguishing main ideas from irrelevant ideas, inadequate reading interest and habits among others. None of these problems eludes most Nigerian secondary schools which as choom in the performance not only in reading comprehension but in other subjects as well. One of the reasons could be the way students are being taught reading comprehension. Some teachers in most schools do not teach students how to scan and skim through a passage in order to have a general idea about a passage, how to make a guess from a passage, how to identify topic sentence from the passage among others. No wonder most of the students are lazy to read passages which also affect the way they answer questions from the passage and later, end up having poor academic achievement in reading comprehension. This is the reason why Fabuyusi (2015) lamented that despite the thousands of hours used in teaching and learning of reading comprehension, many students never develop satisfactory reading skills.
Apart from the reading skill, the teaching and learning process and situations which are the steps that the students take before they become proficient readers are not properly looked at. According to Bauer, Manyak and Cook (2010), reading comprehension improves when teachers and learners provide explicit comprehension strategies. Most Nigerian English language teachers see the use of reading strategies as a waste of time. The majority of them do not make use of the
3
reading resources in the library while teaching reading comprehension despite the fact that these resources has been included in the curriculum, rather, the teachers will only tell the students to open a passage from their reading text. The teacher may appoint one or two students to read a passage after which the teacher reads. Then the students will be asked to answer the questions that follow the passage. Jitendra and Gajira (2011) is of the view that reading comprehension are not often taught correctly. This is the reason why Goldhaber (2016) posits that the teacher factor drastically affects reading comprehension such as inadequate instruction, deficient word recognition skills, insufficient exposure and practice among others.
The background knowledge of a text also helps the students to understand what is being read. According to Kintsch and Vipond (2012), Entwistle (2013), the more background knowledge a learner has that helps to connect with the text being read, the more likely the reader will be able to understand what is being read at that point. The background knowledge will also help the teachers to know those things which the students are familiar with and what they are yet to know. Unfortunately, most of the teachers never cared to know if the students are familiar or understands the topic or not. Rather, their major concern is to tell the students to answer questions from the comprehension passage after which they believe that they have satisfied their conscience without checking if the students can summarize the passage, identify the idiomatic expressions used in the passage, look for the synonyms or antonyms of certain words found in the passage, and this may lead to students’ poor academic achievement in both internal and external examinations.
For students to be able to have high academic achievement in reading comprehension, the teaching and learning process as well as situations must be looked at in order to find out the reason why most learners perform woefully during internal and external examinations in English
4
language. In the WAEC Chief Examiner’s Report (2014), it was stated that students’ poor performances revealed poor understanding of the main idea by giving the surface meaning of the passage, lacking the ability to comprehend well by not being able to read between the lines or draw inferences and concluded that all these pitfalls pointed to the fact that the candidates were not adequately prepared for the examination by the schools. The Chief Examiner suggested that students should strive to cultivate the habit of reading widely with a view to improving their understanding and vocabulary, to read the rubrics and ensure that they understand the questions before attempting them. This problem cannot be averted without looking at the teaching and learning process as well as situation which according to Otagburuagu, Ogenyi, & Ezema (2013) involves the physical milieu in which the language learning activities take place, which are the classroom, the library, the teachers among others.
The library resources and services available in school libraries are therefore expected to be able to support the reading and comprehension in terms of its teaching and learning. Wright and Cervetti (2016) believe that the exchanges and interplay of library resources help teachers and learners to perform well in classroom activities especially when it comes to reading comprehension. To Wright and Cervetti, reading without comprehension is a meaningless part of reading process, since comprehension is an essential part of the process where the reader understands not only the meaning of isolated words but also their meanings when combined in phrases, sentences and longer groups .. In view of this, Adeoye and Popoola (2011) noted that there is need for all teachers and learners to use the resources in the library in order to be efficient and also to improve on their teaching and learning of reading comprehension .. For teachers and learners to achieve the desired level in reading comprehension, utilization of their school’s library resources is of utmost necessity.
5
Library is defined as an organized collection of books and materials printed and non• printed used for study, research, recreation and socialization. However, Goerge (2010) sees library as a collection of resources in a variety of formats that is organized by information professionals or other experts who provide convenient physical, digital, bibliographic, or intellectual access and offer targeted services and programs with the mission of educating, informing, or entertaining a variety of audiences and the goal of stimulating individual learning and advancing society as a whole. Library is divided into special library, public library, virtual library and school or academic library. School library which is the focus of study according to Ugwuanyi (2007), is the nerve centre or the hub around which scholarship revolves because; it is an indispensible instrument for intellectual development. School library is also seen as a place where academic information sources are acquired, organized, processed, stored and made available to meet information needs of the students, teachers and the entire school community (Fari and Ocholla ,2015). This is to say that all the necessary information needed for research is found in the library through the use of the resources available in the library. According to Aina (2014) library is set up to serve its parent institution and considered as an organ around which all academic activities revolve and as a result, can be described as the heart of the school. To Aina, the main purpose of school library is to promote active learning, thus, contributing to students’ ability to think critically and work independently. Hence, all the necessary information needed for research are found in the library through the use of the resources available in it. Thus, library resources are fundamental to student’s learning achievement.
The role of library cannot be overemphasized in schools where it is situated for its academic achievement. According to Matthew (2012) libraries play very important role in schools by providing key prospective students with all the necessary information needed for
6
research. Aina (2014) noted that “library as a nerve centre for academic activity and as an important factor in the quality of its products plays a central role in the academic work of students which are thus: acquisition of resources to support teaching and learning process in schools, provision of resources necessary for research, to meet the requirement of the school, to bring information resource to the door step of students and scholars together under conditions which encourage reading and comprehension, reading for pleasure, self discovery and sharpening the intellectual curiosity of learners”. Based on the role above, library is considered as one of the most important places in the school that enhance reading and comprehension more especially when it is well equipped with the necessary library resources.
Library resources are materials that users consult in making decisions and also for problem solving. Adeoye and Popoola (2011) define library resources as those information bearing materials that are in both printed and electronic format such as: textbooks, magazines, journals, indexes, abstracts, reports, newspapers, filmstrips, computers, articles, dictionaries, charts, journals, encyclopedias among others. To Adeoye (2010) library resources are materials which the users come to consult, read or borrow”. Library resources are the stock in the trade of librarians that is, they are the materials in the library which help in making services possible. Adeoye further explained that library resources are many and varied, but they can be divided into two broad categories namely printed and non- printed materials.
The printed materials are books, pamphlets, periodicals, newspapers and reference resources. Non-printed materials are however resources which are the product of advanced technology that require special equipment to operate and are grouped into three (i.e., Audio, Visual, and audio-visual). All these resources are very essential in the attainment of academic
7
institution’s overall objectives which usually revolve around the development of national human resources.
However, the library resources found in secondary schools which are meant for the teaching and learning of reading comprehension are as follows: dictionaries, textbooks, articles, newspapers, magazines, computers, internet, graphs, filmstrips, overhead projector, talking typewriter, opaque projector, charts among others. All these resources help to improve students’ reading comprehension and vocabulary development since with these resources, the students can make inference based on what they have read. While teaching using magazine or newspaper, the teacher can lift a piece of text from a magazine or newspaper, ask the students to read independently and write out any question they have in mind based on what they read on their notes, after which the questions will be answered by other students in the class. The teacher goes further to tell them to take note of what they already know and put it as a clue as they read the text to make inference on their notes, after which the passage will be read together in the class and students will be asked to summarize what they have read and written on their notes. According to O’Reilly and Sabatini (2013), these are great source of high-interest non-fiction because students are exposed to up-to-date information on a daily, weekly or monthly basis. Snow further added that newspapers/magazines can be used to prepare students for external examination since many of the passages are close in structure.
Furthermore, the teacher can ask the students to read up some passages in an article, storybooks, summarize and copy out those words which seem to be strange to the students. With the use of dictionary, students improve their vocabularies and understanding by looking up the meaning of strange words together with their synonyms and antonyms while reading textbooks, articles etc .Also, the English language teacher can remind the students to use comprehension
8
strategies as they read and to monitor their understanding, ask questions that keep students on track in order to focus their attention on main ideas and important points in the text (Fayose,
2013). With the use of charts, graphs or flashcards, the teacher presents stories through the use of pictures alone, the students will be asked to read the stories and write down what they understand on their notes which should be marked by the teacher for corrections.
With the help of the resources in the library, there will be easy transfer of knowledge and the teachers will be well informed and equipped on the concept of what they want to teach. Based on Fayose’s view, students’ vocabulary will be improved and their understanding of the concept will be very easy since it may not be new again based on their previous experiences. Adeoye and Popoola believe that through the utilization of these resources, learners acquire new knowledge as well as expand the existing ones. According to Fayose (2013), school library provides opportunities for learning wide of variety of learning resources, whereas the classroom provides the teaching therefore, availability of the library resources becomes a necessity in schools.
Availability of library resources is defined as having in stock the necessary resources which the users can lay hands on at any point in time. According to Paterson and Low (2011) availability of relevant library resources means ensuring their presence in the library for immediate use. In other words, this implies not only open shelves but minimization of all other barriers between readers and books. Ugwuanyi (2007) revealed that availability of library resources and its adequacy in quantity and quality promote effective students’ learning activities, while their inadequacy affects students’ performances negatively. Hence, Paterson and Low further added that establishments that have one thousand items of library resources which are effectively used can be a library, while another that has a million document which are not placed
9
for use may simply be a museum or a store house. Schools should make sure that academic libraries are stocked with modem resources and current information, which should be made available and accessible to teachers and learners in teaching and learning of reading comprehension and not obsolete resource. Accessibility of library resources is a means to an end. It is assumed that if resources are available in the school, that it should also be accessible to both
the teachers and students when it comes to teaching and learning. According to Glushko (2013),
accessibility of library resources means the ease of locating and retrieving a piece of information from the storage medium. According to Fari and Ocholla (2015), resources may be available in Nigerian schools and even identified in the catalogue, but the user may not be able to lay hands on them which according to Emasealu (2016) may be as a result of economic, financial, social and environmental factor. Therefore, the more available and accessible library resources are, the more likely they are to be used.
Library resource utilization can be defined as making use of available library resources in order to solve an existing problem. Library resource utilization is defined according to Emasealu (2016) as the practical and maximum use of library materials identified and acquired by users for the purpose of solving a problem. Teachers and students in schools are expected to use library resources for teaching and learning. Effective teaching and learning can be achieved if library resources are correctly applied to teaching and learning functions by the teachers and learners. Hence library resources are of no value to the teachers and students until they have been utilized. That is why (Ikolo, 2015) observes that expectations of people are high when sourcing and retrieving information and when information needs are not met, frustration normally sets in and this may drive the teachers and students away from the library. Mai (2016) believes that satisfying the request of users implies providing actual information or services that will meet
10
their needs. This implies that if their needs are not met, leads to non-utilization of resources in the library by the teachers and students in teaching and learning. Based on that, Nduka (2012) emphasized that neither a good book nor a good library can make the individual educated, it is the successful use of the resources in the library that makes the well informed, viable and well adjusted learned individual. The teacher therefore, should make sure that students are given assignments that will involve using the resources in the library after which it will be discussed in the class for improved comprehension to take place.
Hence, the success of the integration of library resources into teaching and learning of reading comprehension depends mostly on the availability of the resources, level of awareness by the teachers and the actual utilization of the resources in the school. The use of library resources in the teaching and learning of reading comprehension is important. The awareness and use of the library resources especially the visuals and audiovisuals, by teachers and learners of English language right from secondary school become necessary, alongside training teachers and students on the use of the resources in the library in order to acquire the skills and be competent on the use of those library resources. (Fakeye 2010). However, both the teachers and the students should be aware on the need to make use of the resources in the library when it comes to teaching and learning. Teachers and learners should be trained on how to handle some of the resources to avoid being damaged.
Some studies revealed that some of the resources are not available or being utilized by teachers and students in schools. Studies such as Fakeye (2010) and Fayose (2013) by experts reveal that there is lack of library resources especially information and communication technologies for use in most schools. According to Fakeye (2010), the availability of computer and its connectivity to the internet tend to non-existence in virtually all the schools in Enugu
11
State. Based on this, Ibiam and Ugwu (2011) believe that teachers can downgrade the quality of education through laziness, cruelty or incompetence. On the hand, unavailability of the library resources can dampen the spirit of teachers. However, Nnadi (2014) noted that for a long time in Enugu State especially in Obollo-Afor Education Zone, the school system was dominated by the students being passive learners, where the students only dwelt on cramming their notes and few textbooks just to pass internal examinations without looking at the task ahead. Some students never really learnt anything, because there was and there still is a great difference between teaching and learning. However, teaching focuses on the needs of the teacher and the pre• occupation with set syllabuses and examinations. It is external and makes students passive receivers of the teachers’ ideas based on set textbooks. Teaching did not give students the opportunity to think and react positively to situations. Many students actually sit in the classroom not understanding the teachers’ recitals.
Students who actually want to learn how to read and comprehend, need to take charge of their own learning instead of just passively listening to the teacher. The students must be able to carry out plans for developing their reading comprehension whether the teacher is there or not. This can be done more effectively through the use of library resources which assist learning with ease. Therefore, availability and utilization of the resources in schools is an important factor to consider if there must be any meaningful benefit in the use of library resources in the teaching and learning of reading comprehension. Hence, in order to ascertain the extent to which library resources is being used in teaching and learning reading comprehension, it is imperative to look at the availability and utilization of library resources in the teaching and learning of reading comprehension in secondary schools in Obollo-Afor Education Zone.
12
Statement of the Problem
Reading is a complex activity which deals with the decoding of ideas, experiences in order to make meaning out of it. Reading without understanding of what is read is an effortless activity. Therefore, comprehension is highly needed in the process of reading, and when reading is badly taught, it leads to poor academic achievement not only in English language but in other subjects as well.
Despite the importance attached to reading comprehension, it is observed that many students still find it very difficult to read and comprehend materials written in English. In examination, students’ performance in reading comprehension is relatively low even though it is important. In WAEC Paper 1, one comprehension passage is always given compared to other aspects of English which shows its importance. But in all, students’ performances are nothing to write home about. In the WAEC Chief Examiner’s Report (2014), it was noted that students lacked the ability to comprehend well by not being able to read between lines or draw inferences, students’ poor understanding of the main idea by giving the surface meaning of the passage and concluded that all these pitfalls pointed to the fact that the candidates were not adequately prepared for the examination by the schools. The Chief Examiner suggested that students should strive to cultivate the habit of reading widely with a view to improving their understanding and vocabulary, to read the rubrics and ensure that they understand the questions before attempting them.
Many factors can be the cause of students’ poor achievement such as the methods, teaching and learning process as well as situations among others. Fortunately, curriculum planners have included the use of library resources in the teaching and learning of reading comprehension just because of the importance attached to the use of library resources in the
13
teaching and learning of reading comprehension. However, the availability and utilization of library resources in secondary schools for the teaching and learning of reading comprehension has not been comprehensively investigated. The problem of this study, therefore, is to find out the availability and utilization of library resources in the teaching and learning of reading comprehension of secondary schools in Obollo-Afor Education Zone.
Purpose of the Study
The general purpose of this study is to find out the extent of availability and utilization of library resources in the teaching and learning of reading comprehension in secondary schools in Obollo – Afor Education Zone.
Specifically, the study is aimed at finding out:
1. available library resources in the school library.
2. the extent teachers and learners are aware of the need to use the resources in the library.
3. extent of use of the resources in the library.
4. skills possessed by the teachers and students.
5. Challenges posed to the availability and utilization of library resources in the teaching and learning of reading comprehension.
Significance of the Study
The theoretical significance of the work is hinged on Information Utility theory by Ross Todd (2012), and Knowledge Construction Integration theory of comprehension by Van Dijk and Kinstch (2012). Ross Todd’s theory states that a user of information products will keep on demanding and using information resources provided that the user derives maximum satisfaction from the use as long as the resources continue to meet the information needs of the user.’ This theory will provide a framework for understanding users’ (teachers and learners) attitudes
14
towards the utilization of library resources. This is because both the teachers and students will continue to use the available and accessible resources in the teaching and learning of reading comprehension in as much as the resources meet their needs which is the fundamental reason for the utilization of library resources by teachers and learners.
The findings of this study are expected to be beneficial to the students, the teachers, and Ministry of Education. The study is of benefit to students because it exposes them to the available opportunities of library resources such as computer to improve their reading and comprehension and also, be able to perform well both in internal and external examinations as well as in other subjects areas since the mastery of English language helps in students’ performance in other subjects.
It provides teachers with valuable information on the use of library resources in teaching
English reading passages for enhanced comprehension. It will also help the teachers to demand for the improvement of the school libraries for effective utilization of the resources to take place by the users, therefore, enhances teachers’ better attitude towards the utilization of school library resources, hence, the teachers’ job will be made easier if they consult the materials in the library.
The study helps the Ministry of Education to get information on the prevailing situation in schools with regards to the availability and utilization of library resources in schools in the teaching of reading comprehension to know if the resources had been implemented in schools. This will motivate them to increase awareness in schools on the need to incorporate library resources in the teaching and learning of English language skills and reading comprehension through seminars and workshops.
15
Scope of the Study
The study was limited in terms of geographical scope to senior secondary school students (SS2) in Obollo-Afor Education Zone. On the content scope, the available library resources in schools for the teaching and learning of reading comprehension, the extent teachers and learner are aware of the need to use library resources, extent of use of the library resources, skills possessed by the teachers and students, challenges posed to the availability and utilization of library resources in the teaching and learning of reading comprehension.
Research Questions
The following research questions guided this study:
1. What are the available library resources used for the teaching and learning of reading comprehension?
2. To what extent are the teachers and students aware of the need to use the library resources?
3. Which of the available resources are utilized by teachers and students in the teaching and learning of reading comprehension?
4. What are the skills possessed by teachers and students in using library resource to teach reading comprehension?
5. What are the challenges posed to the availability and utilization of library resources in the teaching of reading comprehension?
16
Research Hypotheses
The following null hypotheses were formulated and were tested at 0.05 level of significance.
HO. There is no statistically significant difference in the mean ratings of teachers and students as regards the awareness of the potency of library resources among senior secondary students.
H0. There is no statistically significant difference in the mean ratings of teachers and students as regards the extent of utilization oflibrary resources among senior secondary students.
H0. There is no statistically significant difference in the mean ratings of teachers and students as regards the skills possessed in the use of library resources among senior secondary students.
This material content is developed to serve as a GUIDE for students to conduct academic research
AVAILABILITY AND UTILIZATION OF LIBRARY RESOURCES IN THE TEACHING AND LEARNING OF READING COMPREHENSION IN SECONDARY SCHOOLS IN OBOLLO-AFOR EDUCATION ZONE>
PROJECTOPICS.com Support Team Are Always (24/7) Online To Help You With Your Project
Chat Us on WhatsApp » 07035244445
DO YOU NEED CLARIFICATION? CALL OUR HELP DESK:
07035244445 (Country Code: +234)YOU CAN REACH OUR SUPPORT TEAM VIA MAIL: [email protected]